A Loss Shouldn’t Define a Fighter

Anthony Joshua is at a crossroads in his boxing career.  Not because he dropped his title to Andy Ruiz Jr. a couple weeks back.

It drives me crazy the way the entire professional boxing community today views a loss.  And that includes everyone from fighters-to-networks-to-trainers-to-promoters-to-judges-to fans.

The idea that a loss by a fighter regarded as elite is dire hurts the sport.  It stops fights from happening when they should because someone wants to protect a perfect record (Mayweather) or current box office status (Canelo).

I believe it also corrupts judges who have dinners the night before a fight paid for by the promotion, which truth teller Teddy Atlas has reported.  If a fight is close, a judge is not going to lean toward the promoter’s cash cow after being treated to lobster and champagne (and maybe more) the night before?

There may be more, but I know of 4 champions who retired undefeated:  Rocky Marciano, Floyd Mayweather, Andre Ward and Joe Calzaghe.

Without getting into exactly where they would rank, Marciano and Mayweather are probably among the 50, definitely 75 best fighters of all time.  Ward and Calzaghe are worthy hall-of-famers but not historic.

However, none of them are a patch on the asses of Sugar Ray Robinson or Henry Armstrong.  Those two have a combined 41 losses and 15 draws (BTW-they have a combined 329 wins with 210 KOs).

Let me give you some other more contemporary names:  Sugar Ray Leonard, Muhammad Ali, Carlos Monzon, Marvelous Marvin Hagler, Roberto Duran.  You know what they all have in common?

Two things!  They are all among the best pound-for-pound fighters ever to wear boxing gloves.  Secondly, they all have losses.

What if all these guys were just tossed to the trash heap after a loss?  It would be a pretty short tour through the hall-of-fame.

Outside of a few special guys, and special doesn’t necessarily mean the best, losses are part of the fight game.  You can’t have a great fight without the loser.

So for the most part if you aint lost, you aint been fighting.  Talk soon.

-Marksman

PS:  Nothing, MMA included captures the world’s attention quite the same way boxing does when it’s at it’s best.  The problem is it rarely puts it’s best foot forward.

One of the many things MMA does better (at least for now) than boxing is it doesn’t kick guys to the curb as quickly over a loss as boxing does.  When an elite MMA fighter loses, he remains a factor as long as he can still fight at a very high level.

When an elite boxer loses, he is far too often written off and his winning moments forgotten until he either proves  himself all over again or retires.

Anything Can Happen at Heavyweight

Andy Ruiz Jr. drops Anthony Joshua
photo courtesy of RTE

In boxing or any combat sport, literally anything can happen.  Mismatches occur in all sports but they are magnified in combat sports.

In a team sport one player, even a key player can have a terrible game but if his team is exponentially more talented, they will normally win.

In combat sports you own your off night completely.  So, let’s say a world champion is fighting a fairly unknown, possibly underrated but fringe contender.

That world champion is normally expected by nearly all the viewing public to win in dominant fashion.  But these gladiators are human beings just like you and I.

They have psyches, personal lives, strong courageous moments and dark moments of weakness and self doubt just like us.

What makes them special is they generally have a way of accepting these feelings and dealing with/controlling them better than the average human being.  However, that doesn’t mean those emotions have no effect on their performance; they do, just in more subtle ways.

Now add to the mix that both men are well over 200 lbs. and the unexpected becomes even more possible as anytime a man of that size is proficient in any form of hand-to-hand combat, danger lurks.

The clear favorite usually wins, but upsets happen at a far greater rate at heavyweight.  This is especially true today when top fighters rarely ply their trade more than twice per year making them far less sharp fundamentally even if some look like Mr. Universe.

We had a major upset this past weekend when Unified Heavyweight Champ Anthony Joshua was blitzed by Andy Ruiz Jr.  And this was not just one big punch landed.

Ruiz put the former champ down 4 times over 7 rounds before the stoppage.  In doing so, he got up off the canvas himself.

I did not see the fight live because I had better things to do than go hunting for it on some pay internet channel, but you can view the fight in it’s entirety here.  This is an upset that sniffs the level of James “Buster” Douglas dethroning Mike Tyson  in 1990.

But just to put into perspective where boxing is in society today:  Tyson-Douglas took place in Tokyo.  Joshua-Ruiz took place at Madison Square Garden (the world’s most famous arena).

I remember the Sunday after Tokyo.  Tyson losing was not just the biggest sports story; it was the biggest story period.  Go ask your aunt if she ever heard of Ruiz or Joshua, let alone that there was a fight.

But back to the fight itself.  Ruiz was actually a replacement opponent for Jarrell “Big Baby” Miller who failed PED testing.  Boxing media and fans were making fun of Ruiz’ physique.

Don’t get me wrong, it’s a bad physique but that doesn’t mean he wasn’t in fighting shape; he was.  He had just fought April 20th.

I don’t know that anything was off with Joshua’s personal life but he may have lacked focus.  He was also fighting in the United States for the first time.

Throw in the change in opponents and maybe, just maybe his focus was down a bit.  It shouldn’t happen but it does.

Ruiz on the other hand took all the “fat boy” cracks in stride, showed up, executed his game plan and now sits atop boxing’s glamor division (at least belt-wise).

For most major upsets the stars have to align properly.  Whether you’re talking about Tyson-Douglas, Lewis-Rahman, Moorer-Foreman or whatever-the champion has a physical and/or mental weakness exposed.

But there is another ingredient:  the self belief of the underdog.  He has to truly believe in himself.  And the beauty is that he doesn’t have to be great for a season or even a month or a week.

He just has to be great for a night.  That self belief doesn’t guarantee victory, but the lack thereof sure does guarantee defeat.

As Teddy Atlas often points out, sometimes when a fighter believes, behaves like a fighter and executes a game plan, the world can become fair for just one moment.  He gets rewarded for all his sacrifice and pain.

Now maybe Ruiz is a one night champ like Douglas, but maybe he becomes an unexpected factor in the division for the next 5 years the way Glen Johnson was at light heavyweight last decade.

Whatever happens, we have another big man in the mix of Josua, Tyson Fury and Deontay Wilder.  And whichever direction Ruiz’ career goes from here his name is forever etched in heavyweight history and nobody can EVER take that away from him.

New Champ
courtesy of Business Insider

So yeah, go ahead and call him a fluke.  You may not be wrong.

Go ahead and call him fat.  You’re definitely not wrong.

Just don’t forget to call him CHAMP! Talk soon.

-Marksman

PS:  Upsets like this also put into perspective the greatness of some former heavyweight champions.  Though Rocky Marciano was the only one to retire undefeated, Muhammad Ali, Joe Frazier and Larry Holmes (just to name a few) never suffered an upset in their prime at the hands of a fighter not quite on their level.

See TSS’ Top 10 All Time Heavyweights here.